Showing posts with label Lake Breeze. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Lake Breeze. Show all posts

Thursday, December 1, 2016

Comparing the MYNN and MYJ planetary boundary layer schemes for a Lake Breeze event.

I was the lead author for a paper titles "Impact of Lake Breezes on Summer Ozone Concentration in the Salt Lake Valley." This article was recently accepted in the Journal of Applied Meteorology and Climatology. (see article here: http://journals.ametsoc.org/doi/abs/10.1175/JAMC-D-16-0216.1)

One concern from the reviewers was our use of the MYJ planetary boundary layer scheme. They pointed to evidence that the MYNN scheme was superior, and may improve our results, particularly in the timing of a lake breeze passage on June 18, 2016. We declined to re-run the simulation using the MYNN due to computing resources and time.

I have since re-ran the simulation with the MYNN and found the results are very similar with the MYJ. Below are time series graphs for the stations presented in the paper with the temperature and wind with the MYNN model run overlaid in magenta. The only change between the "WRF" and "MYNN" model data is that the MYNN uses the MYNN PBL scheme instead of the MYJ PBL scheme.
Color and station name denote the observed temperature and wind at the station location. Black dashed is the original WRF simulation, magenta dashed is the same simulation except uses MYNN boundary layer physics.

Temperature and wind patterns between the two runs are very similar. We see that using the MYNN did not change the timing of the lake breeze on this day.

The cause of the observed delay in the lake breeze progression is likely caused by stronger meridional wind component below 5,000 meters (550 mb). In the vertical profiles below, you can see the opposing southerly winds at the Salt Lake City Airport were from the direct south at 10 m/s below an inversion layer at 5,000 m. The HRRR and WRF with MYNN PBL scheme had slightly weaker winds and more from the southwest. This subtle difference is likely the primary reason for the delayed lake breeze on the afternoon of 18 June 2016. The next question is, "how do we fix that subtlety in the model." I'm not sure I know the answer to that.
Vertical profile of potential temperature, mixing ratio, and vector winds at 19 June 2015 00z. Profiles for Salt Lake City Rawinsonde (blue), HRRR analysis (red), HRRR 1-hr forecast (green), and WRF with MYNN PBL Scheme (black) are shown. Notice in the observed sounding the critical level at 5,000 m where there was a temperature inversion. Below this level winds opposed the lake breeze and were directly south while the simulated winds were weaker and more southwesterly than the observed winds. This subtlety is the likely reason why the WRF simulation missed the delayed lake breeze.



Just as a comparison between 3 km and 1 km domains: the lake breeze is much less "sharp" in the outermost domain, run at 3 km (right), than the inner domain run at 1 km (right).
Domain 2 with 1 km grid spacing
Domain 1 with 3 km grid spacing



Thursday, June 18, 2015

Lake Breeze Front moving up Salt Lake Valley

Differential heating of water and land surfaces often causes a pressure gradient to set up between the Great Salt Lake and the surrounding land. This pressure gradient causes winds to blow from the lake to the land on hot clear days like today. From the MesoWest observations shown below you can see the surface winds blow north from the lake. Winds near Draper and Bluffdale, however, are from the south. The lake breeze front hasn't reached that far south at the time this screen shot was taken (7:45 PM)


Doppler radars are used for much more than just tracking rain. We can also how fast the winds are blowing. Below is the radial velocity. That means we measure the speed of objects relative to the radar. A negative value is wind blowing toward the radar, a positive value means wind is blowing away from the radar. Below, the green colors are moving toward the radar (white + north of North Salt Lake) and yellow is moving away form the radar. You can see the lake breeze fill in the Salt Lake valley over time as the winds switch from blowing toward the radar to blowing away from the radar. Also note...this radar is not the National Weather Services' Radar on Promontory Point. This is the TDWR Radar operated by the airport used for aviation and is especially useful for detecting microburst winds during thunderstorms. Since the radar is at ground level it can measure winds closer to the surface. However, there is much more interference from ground clutter and blocking from mountains.

I recently downloaded the raw radar data and plotted it up in IDV. Here is the finished product...

Saturday, April 25, 2015

Final Stats Project: Relationship between Great Salt Lake level and lake breeze from pibal and rawinsonde observations

For those interested in the Great Salt Lake breeze, here is my final project for Environmental Statistics.

Read Here



Also, check out the poster presentation version of the paper here.